Phoebe Atwood Taylor Books in Order

33 books are credited to Phoebe Atwood Taylor, published between 1931 and 1987; 1 of them appeared after Phoebe Atwood Taylor's death in 1976. The first book is The Cape Cod Mystery (1931) and the newest is Murder at the New York World's Fair (As: Freeman Dana) (1987). Publication order is the reading order below.

Phoebe Atwood Taylor also publishes as Alice Tilton, Freeman Dana.

Books
33
Published
1931–1987
Pages on record
5,693 in 21 of 33 books
Reading time
95–142 hours

Reading time is an estimate, not a recorded figure: 5,693 pages at 300 words a page, read at 200300 words a minute, covering the 21 of 33 titles with a page count on record.

Phoebe Atwood Taylor, born in Boston in 1909 and died there in 1976, wrote mystery novels under her own name and as Freeman Dana and Alice Tilton. Her first, The Cape Cod Mystery (1931), introduced Asey Mayo, the Codfish Sherlock, who went on to appear in 24 novels; Leonidas Witherall heads a second series. Taylor drew on her own Boston childhood and her knowledge of Cape Cod for the local detail, and the critic Dilys Winn placed her as the mystery writer's answer to Buster Keaton. She graduated from Barnard College in 1930 and married the surgeon Grantley Walder Taylor in 1951. Thirty-three catalogued titles date from 1931 to 1987.

How many Phoebe Atwood Taylor books are there?

Phoebe Atwood Taylor has 33 books, released between 1931 and 1987. 1 of them were published after Phoebe Atwood Taylor's death in 1976. They include 2 series and 1 title listed outside any series.

Phoebe Atwood Taylor Books in Publication Order

The table lists all 33 Phoebe Atwood Taylor books in the order they were published, with the release year, the page count where one is on record, and how many independent book listings confirm each title. Catalogue data as of September 2026.

  1. 1
    The Cape Cod MysteryAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #11931 · confirmed 1/4
    1931
  2. 2
    Death Lights a CandleAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #21932 · 304 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1932304
  3. 3
    The Mystery of the Cape Cod PlayersAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #31933 · confirmed 1/4
    1933
  4. 4
    The Mystery of the Cape Cod TavernAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #41934 · 288 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1934288
  5. 5
    Sandbar SinisterAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #51934 · 294 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1934294
  6. 6
    The Tinkling SymbolAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #61935 · 288 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1935288
  7. 7
    Deathblow HillAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #71935 · 286 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1935286
  8. 8
    The Crimson PatchAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #81936 · confirmed 1/4
    1936
  9. 9
    Out of OrderAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #91936 · confirmed 1/4
    1936
  10. 10
    Beginning with a BashLeonidas Witherall Mystery #11937 · confirmed 1/4
    1937
  11. 11
    Figure AwayAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #101937 · 286 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1937286
  12. 12
    Octagon HouseAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #111937 · 296 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1937296
  13. 13
    The Cut DirectLeonidas Witherall Mystery #21938 · 288 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1938288
  14. 14
    The Annulet of GiltAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #121938 · 288 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1938288
  15. 15
    Banbury BogAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #131938 · 173 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1938173
  16. 16
    Cold StealLeonidas Witherall Mystery #31939 · 287 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1939287
  17. 17
    Spring HarrowingAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #141939 · confirmed 1/4
    1939
  18. 18
    The Criminal C.O.DAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #151939 · 288 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1939288
  19. 19
    The Left LegLeonidas Witherall Mystery #41940 · confirmed 1/4
    1940
  20. 20
    The Deadly SunshadeAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #161940 · 297 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1940297
  21. 21
    The Hollow ChestLeonidas Witherall Mystery #51941 · 284 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1941284
  22. 22
    The Perennial BoarderAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #171941 · 288 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1941288
  23. 23
    The Six Iron SpidersAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #181942 · 288 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1942288
  24. 24
    Three Plots for Asey MayoAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #191942 · confirmed 1/4
    1942
  25. 25
    File for RecordLeonidas Witherall Mystery #61943 · 240 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1943240
  26. 26
    Going, Going, GoneAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #201943 · 218 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1943218
  27. 27
    Dead ErnestLeonidas Witherall Mystery #71944 · 218 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1944218
  28. 28
    Proof of the PuddingAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #211945 · confirmed 1/4
    1945
  29. 29
    The Asey Mayo TrioAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #221946 · 256 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1946256
  30. 30
    Punch with CareAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #231946 · confirmed 1/4
    1946
  31. 31
    The Iron ClewLeonidas Witherall Mystery #81947 · 238 pages · confirmed 1/4
    1947238
  32. 32
    Diplomatic CorpseAsey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery #241951 · confirmed 1/4
    1951
  33. 331987

Phoebe Atwood Taylor books grouped by series

Each title below is a row in the publication-order table above. None of these groups has a reading-order page of its own on this site.

Asey Mayo Cape Cod Mystery in order

24 books
  1. 1. The Cape Cod Mystery
  2. 2. Death Lights a Candle
  3. 3. The Mystery of the Cape Cod Players
  4. 4. The Mystery of the Cape Cod Tavern
  5. 5. Sandbar Sinister
  6. 6. The Tinkling Symbol
  7. 7. Deathblow Hill
  8. 8. The Crimson Patch
  9. 9. Out of Order
  10. 10. Figure Away
  11. 11. Octagon House
  12. 12. The Annulet of Gilt
  13. and 12 more in the table above

Leonidas Witherall Mystery in order

8 books
  1. 1. Beginning with a Bash
  2. 2. The Cut Direct
  3. 3. Cold Steal
  4. 4. The Left Leg
  5. 5. The Hollow Chest
  6. 6. File for Record
  7. 7. Dead Ernest
  8. 8. The Iron Clew

Standalone books

1 book

1 Phoebe Atwood Taylor title here is not listed as part of any series.

Do you have to read Phoebe Atwood Taylor books in order?

You only need to read Phoebe Atwood Taylor books in order within each series: the books listed here span 2 separate series, and each series has its own publication order.

Where to start with Phoebe Atwood Taylor

Start with The Cape Cod Mystery (1931), the earliest published title.

What is the newest Phoebe Atwood Taylor book?

Murder at the New York World's Fair (As: Freeman Dana) (1987) is the newest Phoebe Atwood Taylor book released so far.

Is there a new Phoebe Atwood Taylor book coming?

No next Phoebe Atwood Taylor book is announced in the catalogue, which is a gap in the listings it merges rather than a sign that the run has ended.

Phoebe Atwood Taylor at a glance

Died
Phoebe Atwood Taylor died in 1976, according to Wikidata.
After death
Books credited to Phoebe Atwood Taylor are still being published after Phoebe Atwood Taylor's death in 1976; the newest appeared in 1987.
Release pace
Phoebe Atwood Taylor books have appeared about one every 2 years on average.
Length
5,693 pages across the 21 of 33 books with a recorded length, a median of 288 pages each.
Busiest decade
Most Phoebe Atwood Taylor books, 18 of 33, were published in the 1930s.

What the Phoebe Atwood Taylor books are about

26 of the 33 Phoebe Atwood Taylor books carry subject tags in Open Library's catalogue. The subjects below are the ones that recur across them, most frequent first: asey mayo (fictitious character) is tagged on 17 of 26. The subjects are cataloguers’ headings, not a plot summary.