Order of Book Series
0

Amish Candy Shop Mystery Books in Order

Amish Candy Shop Mystery by Amanda Flower contains 14 books, published between 2017 and 2026. The first book is Assaulted Caramel (2017) and the newest is Truffle Trouble (2026). One more title is announced: Strawberry Scam (2027). Publication order is the reading order below.

Books
14 + 1 announced
Published
2017–2026
Confirmed
15 of 15 titles
Pages on record
1,248 in 4 of 15 books
See all 15 books in order Printable Amish Candy Shop Mystery checklistNext: Strawberry Scam (2027)

Amish Candy Shop Mystery is a cozy culinary mystery run by Amanda Flower, catalogued as the Amish Candy Shop Mysteries. The run contains 15 books, opening with Assaulted Caramel in 2017. Subject headings cover Amish communities, Ohio, confectioners and murder investigation. Truffle Trouble is the newest release (2026), and Strawberry Scam is scheduled for 2027, so the run is ongoing.

How many Amish Candy Shop Mystery books are there?

Amish Candy Shop Mystery has 14 published books, released between 2017 and 2026. One more, Strawberry Scam (2027), is announced.

Amish Candy Shop Mystery Books in Publication Order

The table lists all 15 Amish Candy Shop Mystery books in the order they were published, with the release year, the page count where one is on record, and how many independent book listings confirm each title. Catalogue data as of September 2026.

  1. Cover of Assaulted Caramel by Amanda Flower, book 1 of the Amish Candy Shop Mysteries series (2017)
  2. Cover of Premeditated Peppermint by Amanda Flower, book 3 of the Amish Candy Shop Mysteries series (2018)
  3. Cover of Toxic Toffee by Amanda Flower, book 4 of the Amish Candy Shop Mysteries series (2019)
  4. Cover of Marshmallow Malice by Amanda Flower, book 6 of the Amish Candy Shop Mysteries series (2020)
  5. Cover of Peanut Butter Panic by Amanda Flower, book 11 of the Amish Candy Shop Mysteries series (2022)
  6. Cover of Blueberry Blunder by Amanda Flower, book 12 of the Amish Candy Shop Mysteries series (2023)
  1. 1
    Assaulted CaramelAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #12017 · 304 pages · confirmed 3/4
    2017304
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  2. 2
    Lethal LicoriceAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #22018 · 304 pages · confirmed 3/4
    2018304
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  3. 3
    Premeditated PeppermintAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #32018 · 304 pages · confirmed 3/4
    2018304
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  4. 4
    Toxic ToffeeAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #42019 · confirmed 3/4
    2019–
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  5. 5
    Criminally CocoaAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #52019 · confirmed 3/4
    2019–
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  6. 6
    Marshmallow MaliceAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #62020 · confirmed 3/4
    2020–
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  7. 7
    Botched ButterscotchAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #72020 · confirmed 3/4
    2020–
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  8. 8
    Candy Cane CrimeAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #82020 · confirmed 3/4
    2020–
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  9. 9
    Lemon Drop DeadAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #92021 · confirmed 3/4
    2021–
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  10. 10
    Amish Candy Shop HolidaysAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #102021 · confirmed 3/4
    2021–
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  11. 11
    Peanut Butter PanicAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #112022 · confirmed 3/4
    2022–
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  12. 12
    Blueberry BlunderAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #122023 · 336 pages · confirmed 3/4
    2023336
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  13. 13
    Gingerbread DangerAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #132024 · confirmed 3/4
    2024–
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  14. 14
    Truffle TroubleAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #142026 · confirmed 3/4
    2026–
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK
  15. 15
    Strawberry ScamAmish Candy Shop Mysteries #152027 · confirmed 3/4
    2027–
    Buy at Amazon USAmazon UK

Do you have to read Amish Candy Shop Mystery books in order?

You should read the Amish Candy Shop Mystery books in publication order, the order of the numbered table above. The catalogue does not record whether each Amish Candy Shop Mystery book also stands alone.

Where to start with Amish Candy Shop Mystery

Start with Assaulted Caramel (2017), the earliest published title.

What is the newest Amish Candy Shop Mystery book?

Truffle Trouble (2026) is the newest Amish Candy Shop Mystery book released so far.

Is there a new Amish Candy Shop Mystery book coming?

Yes. Strawberry Scam (2027) is the next Amish Candy Shop Mystery book announced in the catalogue. A publication year announced this far ahead moves, so it is worth rechecking: every announced title dated after 2026 sits on the upcoming book releases page.

Amish Candy Shop Mystery at a glance

Still running
Amish Candy Shop Mystery is still running. Strawberry Scam is announced for 2027.
Release pace
Amish Candy Shop Mystery books have appeared more than one a year on average.
Length
1,248 pages across the 4 of 15 books with a recorded length, a median of 304 pages each.
Busiest decade
Most Amish Candy Shop Mystery books, 9 of 15, were published in the 2020s.

What the Amish Candy Shop Mystery books are about

4 of the 15 Amish Candy Shop Mystery books carry subject tags in Open Library's catalogue. The subjects below are the ones that recur across them, most frequent first: amish is tagged on 3 of 4. The subjects are cataloguers’ headings, not a plot summary.

  • Amish 3 of 4 books
  • Mystery & detective 3 of 4 books
  • Ohio 2 of 4 books
  • Amish -- Fiction 1 of 4 books
  • Amish & Mennonite 1 of 4 books
  • Confectioners -- Fiction 1 of 4 books
  • Crime 1 of 4 books
  • Murder -- Investigation -- Fiction 1 of 4 books
  • Mystery & detective, cozy, culinary 1 of 4 books

More books by Amanda Flower

The author page linked below lists every book in publication order.