Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Books in Order
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries contains 27 books, published between 2015 and 2025. The first book is Peace Like a River (2015) and the newest is O Little Town of Sugarcreek (2025). Publication order is the reading order below.
- Books
- 27
- Published
- 2015–2025
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries is a multi-author book series of 27 titles in the catalogue. Nancy Mehl and Elizabeth Ludwig are credited on 5 books each, Elizabeth Adams on 4, and Olivia Newport and Amy Lillard on 3 each, with Tricia Goyer, Annalisa Daughety, Cara C. Putman and Emily Thomas also credited. Peace Like a River (2015), credited to Olivia Newport, is listed first, and Blessing in Disguise and Where Hope Dwells share the 2015 date. Most entries are dated 2015 to 2018, and the catalogue marks the series as ongoing.
How many Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries books are there?
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries has 27 books, released between 2015 and 2025.
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries Books in Publication Order
The table lists all 27 Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries books in the order they were published, with the release year and how many independent book listings confirm each title. Catalogue data as of September 2026.
- 1Peace Like a River2015 · confirmed 2/42015–2/4
- 2Blessing in Disguise2015 · confirmed 2/42015–2/4
- 3Where Hope Dwells2015 · confirmed 2/42015–2/4
- 4The Buggy Before the Horse2015 · confirmed 2/42015–2/4
- 5A Season of Secrets2015 · confirmed 2/42015–2/4
- 6O Little Town of Sugarcreek2015 · confirmed 2/42015–2/4
- 7Off the Beaten Path2015 · confirmed 2/42015–2/4
- 8Simply Vanished2016 · confirmed 2/42016–2/4
- 9Stranger Things Have Happened2016 · confirmed 2/42016–2/4
- 10No Time for Trouble2016 · confirmed 2/42016–2/4
- 11A Stitch in Time2016 · confirmed 2/42016–2/4
- 12Shoo, FLY, Shoo2016 · confirmed 2/42016–2/4
- 13Home Sweet Sugarcreek2016 · confirmed 2/42016–2/4
- 14When There's a Will2016 · confirmed 2/42016–2/4
- 15In a Jam2016 · confirmed 2/42016–2/4
- 16All Abuzz at the Honey Bee2016 · confirmed 2/42016–2/4
- 17Mason Jar Mayhem2016 · confirmed 2/42016–2/4
- 18Earthly Treasures2016 · confirmed 2/42016–2/4
- 19A Tempting Taste Of Mystery2017 · confirmed 2/42017–2/4
- 20Digging Up Doubts2017 · confirmed 2/42017–2/4
- 21A Play On Words2017 · confirmed 2/42017–2/4
- 22In the Fullness of Time2017 · confirmed 2/42017–2/4
- 23Horse Sense and Sensibility2017 · confirmed 2/42017–2/4
- 24Secrets Plain and Simple2018 · confirmed 2/42018–2/4
- 25When Angels Whisper2022 · confirmed 2/42022–2/4
- 26Hark! The Herald Angel Falls2024 · confirmed 2/42024–2/4
- 27O Little Town of Sugarcreek2025 · confirmed 2/42025–2/4
Where to start with Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries
Start with Peace Like a River (2015), the earliest published title.
What is the newest Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries book?
O Little Town of Sugarcreek (2025) is the newest Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries book released so far.
Is there a new Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries book coming?
No next Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries book is announced in the catalogue, which is a gap in the listings it merges rather than a sign that the run has ended.
Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries at a glance
- Still running
- Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries is still running, with a title published as recently as 2025.
- Release pace
- Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries books have appeared more than one a year on average.
- Busiest decade
- Most Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries books, 24 of 27, were published in the 2010s.
- Attribution
- Of the 27 titles, 5 are credited to Nancy Mehl, 5 to Elizabeth Ludwig, 4 to Elizabeth Adams and 3 to Olivia Newport. A further 6 writers are credited.